Most of the discussion has centred around adult jehovah s witnesses. Whatever the motivation involved in this question i will try to give an clea. A focus is also placed on the position of jehovah s witness children who refuse blood transfusions in the specific context of english medical law due to the prevalence of related case law in. Why dont jehovahs witnesses accept blood transfusions. Generally, orthodox jws seek and accept the benefits of modern medical care with one notable exception. Jehovahs witness refuse blood product therapy levitus 17. History of avulsion of umbilical cord during delivery resulting in massive blood loss. Consent to treatment is at the heart of this guideline. Opinions of pediatric nurses about jehovahs witnesses.
When such group of people are in need of health care, their faith and belief is an obstacle for their proper treatment, and poses legal, ethical and medical challenges for attending health care provider. Quebec coroner dupuis told doctors she did not want a transfusion, even as. Jehovah s witnesses jws believe their bible forbids them from accepting blood transfusions. Support and management for women who decline the use of blood and blood products phnhs jun 14 as parents we are deeply interested in the welfare of our child ice us 601 care plan for surgery in jehovahs witnesses cps1e bi 908 care plan for women in labour refusing a blood transfusion hisjw jan 2011. Cases involving jehovahs witnesses and blood transfusions. However, where children are involved the issues become more. Caring for patients who refuse blood the majority of jehovah s witnesses carry on their person a signed and witnessed advancedecision card to express their wishes in emergencies. The jehovah s witnesses society is best known to outsiders for its refusal of blood products, even when such a refusal may result in death. Medical emergencies in children of orthodox jehovahs. Jehovah s witnesses believe that faith will heal a persons ailments.
There are a couple of aspects which have not been covered and which i would like to raise. Their decision is not related to perceived risks of transfusion but is a scriptural stand based on biblical texts, such as the life of all. They believe that injecting blood into their veins is the same thing as eating it. The dilemma of jehovahs witness children who need blood to survive. Jehovah s witnesses refuse to donate blood for the benefit of other people, but they partake of the medical benefits that arise from the donated blood supply freely for themselves. Jehovahs witnesses and blood transfusions queens university. Medical treatments that avoid blood transfusions are costeffective. Refusal of potentially lifesaving blood transfusions by. Ethics children of jehovahs witnesses and adolescent. Deliberately induced abortion simply to avoid the birth of an unwanted child is the willful taking of a human life and hence unacceptable. Well, you may be thinking, that phrase keep abstaining from blood. Most witnesses are well informed about their religious teaching, and about their right to refuse treatment. Jehovahs witness nurse and blood transfusion lounge. Judge rules jehovahs witness boy can receive blood transfusion this article is more than 5 years old high court ruling says decision was made in youngsters best interests, despite religious.
The card explicitly refuses blood and primary blood components red cells, white cells, plasma ffp and platelets. A high court judge has ruled a fiveyearold girl from a family of jehovah s witnesses can be given a blood transfusion against her parents wishes. The child was in a sickle cell crisis, with a stroke. Based on their beliefs and core values, jehovah s witnesses refuse blood component transfusion including red cells, plasma and platelets. Quality alternatives to transfusion jehovahs witnesses.
The belief is based on an interpretation of scripture that differs from that of other christian denominations. If jehovah does not approve of intake of blood, would it b. Results in the case of jehovahs witness parents refusal of blood transfusion for their child, italian courts adopt measures that prevents the. Children most jehovah witness parents will refuse blood transfusions for their children. Some patients refuse blood and blood products, in particular, jehovah s witnesses have specific religious beliefs regarding transfusion and their acceptance of particular products may vary e. Judge rules jehovahs witness boy can receive blood. Though this has been recognized from ancient times, modern research is providing a greater understanding of its lifesustaining functions. Ethical issues in parental refusal to consent for blood. Since the introduction of the blood ban in 1945, jw parents have fought for their rights to refuse blood on behalf of their children, based on religious beliefs and their right to raise children as they see fit. In terms of the national health act, if an adult jehovah s witness is unable to consent to or refuse the administration of a blood transfusion ie, due to unconsciousness, a person who had been mandated by the patient, in writing, may consent to or refuse the blood transfusion on behalf of the patient. Adolescent jws have also sought to refuse blood products based on their beliefs, regardless of the views of their parents.
Since the introduction of the blood ban in 1945, jehovah s witness jw parents have fought for their rights to refuse blood on behalf of their children, based on religious beliefs and their right to raise children as they see fit. Jehovahs witnesses and the question of blood watchtower. Despite existing legal solutions, medical staff experiences value conflicts. Judge orders doctors to give jehovahs witness girl blood.
Jehovah s witnesses absolutely refuse having blood transfusion performed. Orthodox canadian jws are members of the watchtower bible and tract society wts, an organization founded in pennsylvania in the 1870s, which now has over six million members worldwide. Considerations in the management of pregnant women who. The patients condition continues to deteriorate, and she is taken to the intensive care unit where she is intubated and mechanically ventilated. Court says ill childs interests outweigh religion the. Jehovahs witnesses do not take blood transfusions, believing this falls under the bibles prohibition against eating blood. Young jehovahs witness who refused a blood transfusion is. If the inline pdf is not rendering correctly, you can download the pdf file here. Jehovahs witnesses believe that the bible prohibits ingesting blood and that christians should not accept blood transfusions or donate or store their own blood for transfusion. Approach to the child of jehovahs witness with a bleeding disorder. This principle is not absolute, as is the case when a jw parent refuses blood for their minor child.
In the case of jehovahs witness parents refusal of blood transfusion. Jehovah s witnesses believe that the bible prohibits the eating of blood. The refusal of jehovah s witness parents article pdf available. In this issue of the journal lee elder,1 a pseudonymous dissident jehovah s witness jw, previously an elder of that faith and still a jw, joins the indefatigable dr muramoto25 the latter is not a jw in arguing that even by their own religious beliefs based on biblical scriptures jws are not required to refuse potentially lifesaving blood transfusions. Risks and legal issues in caring for minor jehovahs. A small group of people belonging to a certain religion, called jehovahs witness do not accept blood transfusion or blood products, based on biblical readings. The situation is even more difficult when the refusal of blood transfusion concerns a child. In particular, jehovah s witnesses have specific religious beliefs regarding transfusion, although when it comes to minor blood fractions or procedures involving the use of their own blood, their acceptance of particular. Yes, parents are legally responsible for their minor children. Jehovahs witnesses and blood transfusions wikipedia. Most jehovah s witnesses refuse to accept fresh blood products however batched products are usually considered matters of conscience for each individual to decide. Especially in view of the fact that it is wellknown a significant percentage of jehovah s witness secretly oppose the policy and feel coerced into carrying the blood card or risk exposure as apostates with subsequent shunning. Because of consistent success in jehovah s witnesses and the fact that blood transfusion carries a risk of serious complications, we are currently performing most of our pediatric cardiac operations without transfusion.
Children of jehovahs witnesses and adolescent jehovahs. As explained in a companion essay, the jehovah s witnesses denomination urges its members to refuse to accept blood transfusions and to not allow them to be given to their children this essay describes a few randomly seleted instances involving refusals to accept blood transfusions. Caring for patients who refuse blood royal college of. A fully informed, competent adult patient is entitled to decide to accept medical treatment or not. Jehovahs witnesses and blood transfusions journal of. Parents who fail to obtain medical treatment for their children, are subject to.
Are jehovas witness parents legally allowed to refuse a. An adult jehovah s witness who is unable to consent to or refuse treatment. Are jehovah s witnesses legally responsible for their minor children. The jehovahs witnesses society jw, a fundamentalist christian sect, is best known to laypersons and healthcare professionals for its refusal of blood products, even when such a refusal may result in death. Constitution protects the freedom to practice religion, courts have not interpreted that freedom to include the right to refuse lifesaving treatment for a child on the basis of that religion 11. With a lack of consistent reasoning on which to base its blood transfusion doctrine, the watchtower consistently relies on fear as a motivator to abstain from blood. Believed to be an act of blood eating that excludes. Approximately 150,000 jehovah s witnesses live in great britain and ireland. Jehovahs witnesses and blood tens of thousands dead in. Parents declined blood products jehovahs witnesses. Brewster, md3 patients who are jehovah s witnesses frequently cross the path of nephrologists when they are acutely ill in the intensive care unit and stable in the longterm setting. It is recommended she get blood, but the patient, a jehovah s witness, refuses a transfusion on religious grounds. Since the introduction of the blood ban in 1945, jw parents have fought for their rights to refuse blood on behalf of their children. Guidelines for the management of jehovahs witness patients and others who refuse blood transfusions.
Issues raised when treating a jehovah s witness megan l. Mother is member of jehovah s witness religion, no blood transfusions. As you are probably aware, jehovahs witnesses do not give or take blood transfusions. Royal children s hospital blood refusal management of procedure october 2017 3 transfusion is likely to be refused in any circumstance. Would heshe be able to decline to give or take blood transfusions to patients due to religious convictions. A focus is also placed on the position of jehovahs witness children who refuse blood transfusions in the specific context of english medical law. The full text of this article in pdf format can be obtained by clicking here. Some patients, including pregnant women, refuse blood and blood products. In the case that led to the other decision, norwood hospital sought permission in april 1989 to treat the woman, yolanda munoz, 38, a jehovah s witness from dedham, with blood. Why do jehovah s witnesses refuse blood transfusions. They regard nonconsensual transfusion as a physical violation. Should bioethical deliberations consider dissidents views, j med ethics 24 1998 223230. The pediatric jehovahs witness jehovah s witness patients may present a special challenge to anesthesiologists when there is a risk of blood loss and the possible necessity of a lifesaving transfusion of blood products. Care of the pediatric patient adds another layer of complexity to perioperative.
1312 1100 62 1550 996 1249 1046 1355 1403 1108 1492 923 1571 1438 693 1383 1517 716 241 1057 687 311 250 476 73 759 1589 118 1355 1573 1136 1063 1630 308 1075 614 650 483 645 1310 1141 1124 958